This question already has an answer here:

System: Ubuntu MATE 17.04

I use control\shift + [key] keybinds often, and plan to use lot of hotkeys with those modifiers. Because sometimes using grid layout I will need to be pressing buttons like "F5-F8" with modifiers, or use "q", "a", "z" (which are pressed with pinky finger) with shift\control, having to shift whole hand to do that can be sub-optimal, unless you have both hands on keyboard, so when you use mouse it makes such hotkeys not optimal.

For that reason I am in need to bind additional mouse keys to be "Shift\Control" modifiers, so I could press "Mouse_8 + [key]" and it would process it as "Shift + [key]".

Because there are hotkeys with ctrl\shift all across keyboard, and because shift press can be used by itself to modify mouse panning behavior, just binding each "Mouse_8 + [key]" separately is no good.
For example I could just do separate binds like this:
"Mouse_8 + F1" = "Shift + F1"
"Mouse_8 + F2" = "Shift + F2"
"Mouse_8 + F3" = "Shift + F3"
"Mouse_8 + F4" = "Shift + F4"

But this would create need to have complex xbindkeyscript, complicate rebinding process, and it will mean using mouse button in same way as shift for panning will be impossible.

What I tried:

  • using xmodmap -e "Pointer_Button8 = Shift_R" and the like (it does not recognize mouse buttons above 5, so there are no Pointer_Button8 for it to process)
  • xbindkeys with normal .xbindkeysrc config file like this:

    "xdotool keydown Shift_L"
    "xdotool keyup Shift_L"
    Shift + b:8 + Release
  • xbindkeys with Guile based config in .xindkeysrc.scm:

;;  This configuration is guile based.
;;  http://www.gnu.org/software/guile/guile.html

(define actionperformed 0)

(define (first-binding)
"First binding"
;; backwards\left side mouse button
(xbindkey-function '("b:8") b8-second-binding)

(define (reset-first-binding)
"reset first binding"


(define (b8-second-binding)
"Backwards Button Extra Functions"

(run-command "echo b8 Pressed!")
(run-command "xdotool keydown Shift_L")

(xbindkey-function '(release shift "b:8") (lambda ()
(run-command "echo b8 Released!")
(run-command "xdotool keyup Shift_L")

;; (debug)

; End of xbindkeys configuration ;

Current wall for this solution is fact that xbindkeys blocks anything else from processing key combinations with shift until mouse button is released.
In other words, when I press Mouse_8 it does correctly send command of Shift_L going down, but any hotkeys will not be processed because xbindkeys does not release control of it until you unpress Mouse_8.
Because there is no event like "Mouse_8 down" in xbindkeys,I struggle to find solution.
Trying to emulate "Mouse_8 up" after making it hold down shift to make it think we released button does not work either (I've tried making it "xdotool keydown Shift_L mouseup 8", but xbindkeys did not process it as Mouse_8 being released).

What alternative solutions can I try to bind mouse key as shift modifier, or how can I implement solution in xbindkeys\make it think we releases button so it released control before "release b:8" event?

marked as duplicate by Charles Green, Community Dec 11 '17 at 19:26

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.