4

I noticed that the file source package in Ubuntu on Launchpad is connected to the wrong upstream project. This obviously can't be fixed from Ask Ubuntu, but I am hoping someone can tell me what I can do to get it fixed (or, if for some reason it is best left unfixed, explain that).

Two screenshot clippings to help illustrate the problem I am asking how to report, in case the above description is confusing.

I believe I should report this as a bug, but how?1 Assuming I am even right about that, what project on Launchpad should I report it against? Launchpad itself? Ubuntu with no package specified? (This can be done, but it's usually discouraged.) file in Ubuntu? Note that this is not a problem with the file package itself.

I don't think Launchpad will allow me to change the upstream connection myself. But even if it does, I don't think I should do that without more information, so in effect I need to file a bug report or otherwise enlist the help of others in an appropriate way.2 What should I do?


1 To try and figure out what to report this bug against, I re-read ReportingBugs, checked FindRightPackage (which does not appear to cover this sort of situation) and reviewed How do I report a bug? (Those resources are mainly for reporting bugs in software running on one's Ubuntu system, so it makes sense to me that I didn't find what I was looking for.) I also browsed and searched the Launchpad Help.

2 This is because, even though the current upstream connection is clearly incorrect, I'm not sure how it is best fixed. I can expand this question with more details about that on request, but I've avoided that for now because I don't want to create the appearance that I am attempting to report this problem here rather than in an actual bug report, and because I doubt it will affect the answer to my question.

2

I don't think Launchpad will allow me to change the upstream connection myself.

It does - that's what the yellow icon next to the upstream link is (the red icon is for removing the link). The link is obviously wrong, so I have gone ahead and removed it, so now Launchpad shows this instead:

enter image description here

I don't think there's a project registered on Launchpad for the file command. Now:

  • Anybody can register a project, but of course it's preferable if someone actually involved with the project creates it.
  • There's no actual need for an upstream project for file to be registered in Launchpad: I doubt they will use it for announcements, code releases, bug tracking or anything else that LP offers.
  • If you feel that an upstream project should exist, I'd ask the maintainer of the package about the best course of action (maybe they can create the project, or ask someone from upstream if they're interested). But:

    Christoph Biedl does not use Launchpad. This page was created on 2011-09-07 when the certificatepatrol package was imported into Sid.

This is not a bug with LP - projects and upstream connections are created by LP users, so this is likely user error.

I suggest that you ask the maintainer by posting a question on LP (questions can be converted to bugs and vice versa, if needed), but clearly nobody involved with file is interested in LP, so why bother?


You could also ask the LP Registry Administrators team to make a dummy project for file:

We own and register many projects in Launchpad, but we are always looking to hand them off to their official owners.

They own projects like coreutils (whose maintainers also probably have no interest in a presence on LP).

  • Thanks for the fast and thorough answer! I should've tried removing the connection, especially given the red minus-sign icon. Following your lead, I've gone ahead and removed it from the specific release series pages where it still existed (then, now) and posted an LP question stating what's been done and asking if there is any further action that ought to be taken. – Eliah Kagan Sep 1 '17 at 3:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.