I just switched to 16.04 server from 14.04 server. With Upstart I used to start my server with a file that I had in /etc/rcS.d called M95. M95 was called by /etc/rc.local. Now with systemd I have written a file in /etc/systemd/system called my.service. It looks like this:


ExecStart=/bin/sh rc.local


When I type "/bin/sh rc.local" into the command line my server does start. When I try to start the service by doing "systemctl start my.service" nothing happens.

The relevant lines in journalctl -b are:

Started MyService.
eth0 ...(basically the info I see from ifconfig)
root : TTY=unknown ; PWD=/etc ; USER=root ; COMMAND=/etc/rcS.d/M95
pam_unix(sudo:session): session opened for user root by (uid=0)
$File not found:: /new/den-routes
udhcpd already running
pam_unix(sudo:session): session closed for user root
/bin/rm: cannot remove '/var/log/rewriting-net-rules': No such file or directory.

In rc.local it looks like:

#!/bin/sh -e
sudo /etc/rcS.d/M95
/bin/rm /var/log/rewriting-net-rules

exit 0

In M95 it starts udhcpd (which is where the "udhcpd already running" message comes from) and at the end starts the server by saying:

cd /new
/bin/sh StartServer&

It seems that it does get to M95 because messages are getting logged from it, but the server does not start. When I run these files in the command line it works, but as the service it does not work. I am very unfamiliar with systemd so I have no idea if I am doing this correctly. For a week I have been reading examples and tutorials for it but I am still unsure how this works and how the service file should be written.

Edit: Here is my StartServer file:

nohup /jre/jdk1.8.0_101/jre/bin/myserver -Xrs -Xmx1000m -jar /new/MyServer.jar nowd &

It runs just fine when I start it from the command line. It runs when I call it from my.service. I put in some echos to see that it gets through the whole file, but myserver and MyServer.jar don't start for some reason.


My goodness, there are a lot of things wrong here.

  • You aren't running your service directly; but instead your service unit is running a shell that interprets rc.local in working directory /etc. This despite the fact that systemd has a pre-supplied service unit for running /etc/rc.local if one really wants to. (rc.local is a mechanism that has been superseded three times over on Ubuntu, first by van Smoorenburg rc, then by upstart, then by systemd.)
  • But /etc/rc.local isn't running your service either. Instead it is invoking sudo, despite the fact that it is already running as the superuser.
  • That's in turn running a (second) script from /etc/rcS.d, despite the fact that directory is a symbolic link farm that isn't supposed to contain actual rc script files.
  • That script runs by hand dæmons that systemd is clearly already running as actual services.
  • It thinks that the working directory should be /new not /etc.
  • But even that isn't your service. Instead it is forking a shell to interpret a third script named StartServer.
  • It's not using exec to overlay itself.
  • It's using & to run that shell asynchronously.
  • That fourth script is then forking and running a Java program.
  • It too is not using exec to overlay itself.
  • And the icing on the cake is that that is also using & to run that Java program asynchronously.

None of this is necessary.

And you appear for no apparent reason to have plonked it in the middle of a mechanism for re-setting MAC addresses in cloned virtual machines.


ExecStart=/jre/jdk1.8.0_101/jre/bin/myserver -Xrs -Xmx1000m -jar /new/MyServer.jar nowd


There's also clearly an After= addition needed for whatever it is that is writing out the den-routes file that your dæmon is expecting; you, however, not providing any information to determine what that is.

Further reading

  • Very professional – WinEunuuchs2Unix Sep 29 '16 at 20:10
  • I changed the service file as you suggested. It still does not work. So I will add an edit showing my StartServer file. – khm Sep 30 '16 at 12:44

It turned out the problem was in a piece of code in rc.local. A line that someone put in trying to remove a file would produce an error and cause the program to exit if the file didn't exist. I am not sure why it did not produce this error when I ran it in the command line, but when run using a service, it stopped everything from working.

I fixed it by adding an if statement to check if that file exists before I try to remove it.

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.