5

I'm currently looking for a native Music Player and Library Organizer, which supports Audio CD ripping with CDDB lookup.

I know there's Banshee, but it's a Mono-executed .NET program, which doesn't work well on my computer. So this is why I'm looking for a native program.

I know that there are standalone rippers like RipperX, but I'd prefer a solution which has the ripper included in the music player.

My currently preferred music player is Clementine, which can play Audio CD's, but fails at ripping them. It'd be nice if there was a ripping plugin for Clementine, since I would rather keep my current player.

6

There are players that can rip audio CDs, but one should consider the fact that this procedure may be tricky, not all are equally good, and specialized tools would fit the purpose better: Sound Juicer and Asunder in Gnome and related desktops, Audex, SoundKonverter and Asunder in KDE.

One of the most striking difference between all these (whether players or separate ripping tools) comes with CDs for which the metadata is not easy to find. You may need to try different tools to get the proper track names, so it's better to have 2 or 3 different such tools installed. (From my experience, Deadbeef, Qmmp, Amarok and Asunder rarely miss.)

That said, the already mentioned Rhythmbox is fine, except in KDE. For KDE, see below. It can even read the CD-Text data (track info present on the CD itself that can be accessed offline but not all players can read)


Deadbeef can work very well on all desktops and it is very light.

To get the CDDB info, version 6.2 needs you to un-check the option "Prefer CD-Text over CDDB" (under Preferences-Plugins-Audio CD player-Configure) - because of a bug.

enter image description here

Deadbeef can also read CD-Text.

In the past some codecs needed to be installed - like so - possibly this is not needed, but you can test

sudo apt-get install faac flac lame musepack-tools vorbis-tools wavpack

enter image description here

To start an Audio CD directly in Deadbeef the command to use is deadbeef all.cda. (That can be used in a launcher/icon etc.)

Wait for the CDDB metadata or CD-Text to be read. Before converting, you may select files and reload CDDB

enter image description here

enter image description here

To adjust converting settings, one cannot edit or remove the default configurations, but new ones can be created based on the default ones. Just select one of those as if to edit,

enter image description here

then select copy:

enter image description here

that will open the 'add new encoder' window. Make changes there (for example, for FLAC, level 8 is maximum compression), press ok and a new configuration is added.

enter image description here

More details in a special answer on this topic,here.

enter image description here


Banshee is still a good solution (but avoid it in KDE).

enter image description here

Once inserted, the Audio CD is displayed in the left pane. Select it, it will fetch the online track info. Press Import CD in the top right corner to rip. To set the ripping options right click Audio CD in the left pane, Audio CD Preferences (OR - Edit - Preferences in main menus), then: Source specific - Source - Audio CDs

enter image description here

You can chose between Wav, mp3, flac and ogg with various settings. It has a somewhat limited capacity of finding cd info online. Tracks go to ~./Music folder.


Qmmp - present in repos, but it's better to install the latest version

sudo add-apt-repository ppa:forkotov02/ppa
sudo apt-get update
sudo apt-get install qmmp qmmp-plugin-pack

It seems to lack an internal menu option to open audio CDs, but that can be easily fixed following this answer.

Enable converter and decoders plugins.

enter image description here

(At the plugins settings you can change also the interface: replacing the "skinned" Winamp-like user interface with the "simpler" one, which in fact is more fully-featured to easily access tabs, files and folders, etc. But the following does not depend on that.)

After opening the audio CD, Qmmp looks for proper names etc. Select them all, and go to 'Actions' -'Convert'.

enter image description here


Exaile version 3.4 and above can see the cd easily

The 14.04 version is 3.3 and lacks that. To install latest in 14.04:

sudo add-apt-repository -y ppa:nilarimogard/webupd8

sudo apt-get update

sudo apt-get install exaile exaile-plugin-contextinfo exaile-plugin-ipod exaile-plugin-moodbar

enter image description here

Click Import CD button above the list and it will convert the cd to flac in ~./

It works fine in both KDE and Gnome&co.


In KDE.

Amarok.

Just inserting a cd and starting the player you get the Audio CD entry inside Media sources - Local Music pane.

Right-click cd title: 'Copy to collection' > 'Local collection'

enter image description here

There you can select formats and advanced options

enter image description here

enter image description here

Then you can set tags, location (default ./Music), etc

enter image description here

Proceed, and you'll see the progress in the lower part of the player window.

Amarok can also read CD-Text. Ripping seems to take longer with this tool than with others.

Deadbeef is my favourite.

2

Rhythmbox may be ideal - I think it is/was the default music player for Gnome. It sorts the library of music, so you can browse it easily:

Can search it:

As well as organise playlists, show visualizations, track change notifications, crossfade tracks, and use various plugins:

It can also rip Music from CDs - CDs should show under 'Devices', and can be ripped by pressing 'Extract' - it will also notify if you have previously ripped the CD and will overwrite any changes:

The CD will be saved under the Music directory, under the appropriate Artist/Album values:

N.B. done with a bad exemplar CD (no track info at all), and Rhythmbox 2.99.1

  • Yeah, Rhythmbox is the Ubuntu/Unity default. But does it implement CDDB lookup? Tell me if I'm wrong, but I don't think so. – s3lph Oct 27 '14 at 19:40
  • Depends on what you want to look up - it looks up cover art, and can find it most of the time - other info can be found via the context pane plugin, which seems to require last.fm sync, otherwise just shows links to Allmusic, Wikipedia, etc. – Wilf Oct 27 '14 at 21:48
  • Yes, actually I want to fetch the song information: Artist, Album, Name, etc. and embed it as ID3 tags. Can Rhythmbox do this without last.fm? – s3lph Oct 28 '14 at 20:05
  • is it limited to ogg? – user47206 Jan 12 '16 at 17:04
  • Rhythmbox can fetch online media tags – user47206 Jan 12 '16 at 17:59
1

This is an old thread but I was looking for some answers for the same question and it seems lot of people didn't understand the question properly, so here my answer as of January 2019 and Debian 9.6

Rhythmbox 3.4.1 / Banshee 2.6.2 use MusicBrainz (so, they dont help)

VLC 3.0.3 is not using MusicBrainz, it uses FreeDB and has better results (at least for my CDs). Unfortunately, riping is cumbersome (just found some old basic lua script)

Asunder 2.8 also uses FreeDB explicitly and it works fine -just as a CD ripper. additionally

My solution for now: Asunder for CD rip only, then a Music Player (like Quod Libet or Clementine)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.