3

I have a HP Spectre (intel i7 6500 U). I have been using 16.04, and installed 18.04 recently. I don't travel much, so I use EGPU to gain more GPU power all the time. I have a razer core at home and an Omen Accelerator in my office; and I have a GTX 970 and a GTX 1080ti. With 16.04, everything is working smoothly: I connect the GPU dock to the laptop via the thunderbolt 3 connector and use the prime-select tool to select NVIDIA. Even CUDA is working fine.

However, with 18.04, things have been difficult. Firstly, when I used nouveau, the desktop simply froze after I logged in. Secondly, I installed the NVIDIA-390 driver directly through the Bionic repo. The installation seemed fine, and did not report any error. However, when I connected the GPU dock to the laptop, the error PKCS#7 appeared continuously.

See Picture 1

I could logged in via xorg, but the nouveau was loaded insteaf of NVIDIA. Moreovoer, nvidia-smi showed that the driver was not loaded. Finally, I installed NVIDIA-390 via the run file. This time nvidia-smi showed that the driver was loaded correctly, but I had the login loop for the xorg. S trangely, most people don't see the wayland option when they have installed NVIDIA driver, but I can see both the wayland and xorg options in all circumstances. I have

So in summary, Nouveau makes my laptop with EGPU freeze; installation of nvidia-390 from the bionic repo does not load the driver properly; the installation of nvidia-390 through the run file seems alright but gives me the login loop.

Other than my laptop, I have a desktop with an NVIDIA 970, which works very smoothly under 18.04, including EGPU and cuda.

Any suggestion is deeply appreciated.

  • Did you check that secure boot is off? – ubfan1 May 15 '18 at 1:16
  • Thank you for you reply. But secure boot is off. Everything is fine with 16.04, and the installation for 18.04 is not complaining. – Xdedm Meng May 15 '18 at 7:51
3

Problem solved. I hope it will be useful for people having an Intel+Nvidia Egpu system like mine. Firstly, installation of nvidia 390 from the bionic repo doesn't work for me. Possibly the DKMS is not written correctly. When I use run file, things work, and I can use nvidia-smi to see my nvidia card information. Secondly, Nvidia seems unable to create the correct xorg.conf file in this situation, which results in the login loop. I copied the xorg file from my 16.04 partition and pasted it into /etc/X11/, then everything works. Perhaps the system loads the wrong xorg file Nvidia created, so that the system simply refuses to log in.

It is a bit painful, as the xorg file has to be manually adapted if you connect the computer to a different EGPU dock or if the laptop is running without the EGPU dock. I simply use the wayland session when the EGPU dock is not used.

|improve this answer|||||
  • Could you post your xorg file here? – Richard Aug 25 '19 at 19:36
  • yes, @Xdedm Meng please post the xorg file, I am unsure what to use – robmsmt Jan 4 at 14:53
  • you should check github.com/hertg/egpu-switcher it generates the xorg.conf files for you – dzang Feb 25 at 11:21
  • Sorry I haven't logged into my account for ages... I have switched to Manjaro, and I am using a laptop with another Nvidia GPU, so I am not sure if my xorg file will be useful for other distributions or for a Intel+Nvidia EGPU system. There are a few important things perhaps you can try. Firstly, "Option "AllowExternalGpus"" need to be added to to the xorg first, otherwise, nvidia-settings can not see the EGPU. Secondly, since Nvidia driver 440, you need to add another command "Option "AllowEmptyInitialConfiguration"". I put both in the 'device' section. – Xdedm Meng Feb 26 at 19:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.