Take the 2-minute tour ×
Ask Ubuntu is a question and answer site for Ubuntu users and developers. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I want to run and install some applications on my Linux distributions on the VirtualBox. So what is better 'live' versions or full installs on the VirtualBox? What is the difference between the two (regarding features and required configurations)?

I use, Toshiba Satellite p755-s5215:

  • RAM: 5GB
  • Processor: Intel i3
  • CPU: 2.10GHz
  • Graphics: Sandybridge Mobile
  • OS: 64bit
share|improve this question
1  
What is your idea of a 'live' version? If you mean 'live cd' then that is -not- suited for regular usage since it is meant to be a first impression and to see if all runs on your system. For a VBox install you need to install Linux/Ubuntu into that VBox. –  Rinzwind Oct 29 '12 at 14:09
    
i have created a VBox installation using the .iso file, but still when i use it i see an icon 'install' in the distro, –  abh-kirrack Oct 29 '12 at 14:49
1  
@abh-kirrack: you will have to remove the .iso from virtual box to boot to your installation –  Takkat Oct 29 '12 at 15:34

2 Answers 2

up vote 4 down vote accepted

Let me outline two exemplary cases of running Ubuntu in Virtual Box:

  1. Occasional testing of softwares in different Ubuntu versions
    We may not want to take the time, and we may not have the hard disk space for a full installation. In this case we may just boot a live session where we install our application for testing. This installation will not be available after a reboot of our VM (but of course it will survive a snapshot).

    Disadvantages:

    • The guest OS is not upgraded, therefore bugs will not have been fixed
    • No acess to features from guest additions (i.e. 3D graphics)
    • Installation of additional librariers or software are volatile
  2. Testing software on a customized guest OS
    In case our software has additional dependencies, or we need additional applications for debugging we may not want to load them each time we install the application but rather have an upgraded or customized guest OS for testing purposes.

    Disadvantages:

    • Time needed for installation
    • Some hard disk space needed for the VM image

We can see that it depends much on the use case when a live system or a full install may be better.

I have both of them at hand to decide this from case to case.

Due to restrictions from a virtualized OS you will never have the performance you have from an installation on bare metal. If performance or 3D capability matters I'd therfore recommend a dual boot installation.


Pre-built virtual machines with Ubuntu as a guest OS are not recommended:

  • These machines are customized in a way we can not control (worst of all they will have a predefined fixed hard drive space).
  • There is no guarantee that these machines are free of unwanted additions.
  • They do not come with an up-to-date upgraded Os, which is a further security issue.
  • They are not built on the most recent Virtual Box version, therefore guest additions will have to be reinstalled.

There is not really a benefit from these prebuilt machines as the downloads are much larger as compared to the Ubuntu installation CD. In my experience the additional time for download, and the need for additional tweaking to meet our needs (upgrading, setting locale, set up users, etc.) outweighs far the time you'd need to just install Ubuntu from scratch (should take roughly 20 mins.).

Note that even the most known site for pre-built virtual machines, VirtualBoxes will let you perform a real installation from their download as can be seen from the following note:

the installation is done from the CD, with default parameters set.

share|improve this answer

I'd recommend installed versions. Reasons:

  • You can keep them lean and fast by uninstalling unneeded software
  • Installations make better use of your hardware profile (e.g. 64bit/32bit, CPU)
  • Pre-built images of major distribution installations are available for download, here or here

Live versions are usually reset to factory settings when rebooted, so they might be no use for you anyway.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.