Generally speaking the open source driver isn't as good as a closed source driver as you probably already know, but looking at recent updates it appears the gap is closing in on some cards in some areas, but it is always a mixed bag that open usually looses.
Ultimately it is up to you which works best and which to choose. If everything is working fine then that isn't to say you would have an even better experience with the closed source drivers.
A good source of benchmarks is http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd_r600g_compete12&num=1
Which gives a run down on this exact thing.
If I was you I would test both and see which one worked for me. If the open source driver works perfectly that is just one less thing you need to fool around with post install.
If GNU Freedom is a concern then you have only one choice.
Hope this helps.