Take the 2-minute tour ×
Ask Ubuntu is a question and answer site for Ubuntu users and developers. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Evaluating burning programs is difficult: it takes more time to find how things really are, and meanwhile the errors are very unpleasant. Also, a lot of people, in Linux as well as in Windows, seem to take it very lightly when evaluating burning software. I have read along the years a lot of good comments on all sort of Windows programs that after a while prove not to worth trying - at the expense of my time, lost data and nerves. Burning software is good until it is proved otherwise, which usually doesn't take to long. They should be discussed against reliable benchmarks set by well confirmed software: Nero, and lately ImgBurn (and maybe also CDBurnerXP) in Windows.

I have looked at AcetoneISO, Brasero, and K3B (which many recommend) but they seem more limited than the mentioned Windows apps. They are all said to work, but then at a more basic level (create ISO, burn them, etc.). When it comes to something like creating a DVD movie disk from DVD movie files present on the hard drive, it seems to me that I would have to firstly create the ISO and then burn it, which involves using more hard drive space and more time.

My own experience with the most recommended Ubuntu burning software (k3b, k9copy) was bad. (Could it be related to their k-related condition and my Xfce DE?)

One is not bound to give a second try to one peace of software that crashes or gives an unreadable disk the first time. In Ubuntu the situation on the matter is for now similar to that in Windows of some years ago when Nero ruled unrivaled. Until came ImgBurn - which, yes, works in Wine.

(There is a Nero 4 for Linux. It costs money. The sweetest taboo.)

What other options are there?

(I am in Xubuntu 11.10).

share|improve this question

1 Answer 1

up vote 1 down vote accepted

I'm using K9copy, and I love it.

k9copy provides the following features:

  • The video stream can be compressed to make the video fit on any configurable target size
  • DVD Burning
  • Transcode DVD using mencoder or ffmpeg with configurable presets
  • Creation of ISO images
  • The possibility of choosing which audio and subtitle tracks to copy
  • Title preview (video only)
  • The ability to preserve the original menus 1

You can get it at the USC

1Source:Ubuntu Apps Directory

Another option to create a DVD movie disk from DVD movie files present on the hard drive, Use Bombono

Bombono DVD is easy to use program for making DVD-Video. The main features of Bombono DVD are:

  • excellent MPEG viewer: Timeline and Monitor
  • real WYSIWYG Menu Editor with live thumbnails
  • comfortable Drag-N-Drop support
  • you can author to folder, make ISO-image or burn directly to DVD
  • reauthoring: you can import video from DVD discs. 2

2Source:Ubuntu Apps Directory

share|improve this answer
    
for whatever reason Bombono won't run - but K9copy seems promising considering what I asked –  cipricus Jul 6 '12 at 9:25
    
sorry to say that while Bombono still doesn't wish to start, i also tried K9copy and it crashed when opening a dvd to copy (for testing purposes) - the same dvd that imgburn in wine was able to copy in wine. –  cipricus Jul 6 '12 at 11:43
    
Actually, I used K9copy yesterday, about 5 or six times, with no problems. I'm running 12.04, what release of Ubuntu are you running? –  Mitch Jul 6 '12 at 11:49
    
Xubuntu 11.10. Such are the mysteries of the burning world.I edited my question to put it in perspective. Or maybe the high quality of hardware is a factor. Or having something to do with KDE related stuff that I (or you) have or have not installed. Something to do with Xfce? –  cipricus Jul 6 '12 at 12:23
    
I am not only practically but ... theoretically interested in such stuff so I am not bound to let it go easily and will edit my question accordingly: it might be related to Xfce. The dvd that K9copy stumbled upon was created by me. But it was copied no problem by imgburn in wine. –  cipricus Jul 6 '12 at 12:29

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.