Take the 2-minute tour ×
Ask Ubuntu is a question and answer site for Ubuntu users and developers. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'm using ubuntu 12.04 with gnome-shell and "mediaplayer-extension" from https://extensions.gnome.org/extension/55/. When i hit the close button on a music player, like rhythmbox 2.9x, it hides somewhere, but it keeps playing music in the background. But if i try to do the same on another distro, when I hit the close button, rhythmbox quits instantly.

The question is: What's the program/app/daemon's name that "plays" music in background even if i try to quit rhythmbox (or any music player without a tray-icon) with "close" button? If i try to remove that program, will rhythmbox (or any music player) quit on "close" button? (because i need that)

I know it isn't "mediaplayer-extension" nor "rhythmbox-client", but i can't identify the program. Can somebody help me? Thanks.

(My native language isn't english so i don't know if it's well drafted.)

edit
For clarification, what I'm wondering is:
Why does rhythmbox hide on Ubuntu by hitting on "close" button instead of quitting it?

Why does rhythmbox quit on Fedora by hitting on "close" button instead of hiding it?

Is there a program that modifies rhythmbox's behaviour in ubuntu that fedora doesn't have, or viceversa?

edit 2

It doesn't only happen in rhythmbox. If i use another music player, like quodlibet or banshee (both without tray icon), it keeps playing music on Ubuntu, but quits instantly on Fedora when i hit on the same "close" button.

Is that (hide-on-close) a normal behaviour that i can only find on Ubuntu?

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

It's still Rhythmbox, but I suspect that you may have a different version of Rhythmbox on the other distros which is why you see different behavior. There has been some back and forthing over the behavior of Rhythmbox's close button.

But currently, on Ubuntu 12.04, the Rhythmbox close button is simply hiding the player's shell. The player is still running and playing your tracks.

share|improve this answer

The purpose (and why you probably installed it) of the GNOME shell extension Media Player Indicator is to control the media players in your system over a indicator applet. This includes starting and stopping the player via the MPRIS D-Bus implementation that Rhythmbox offers. There is a similar implementation in the Unity Sound Menu/Indicator Sound.

The way it should operate by design is that whenever you close the window of a media player while it is playing it should minimize. The application that plays sound still will be Rhythmbox. In case the player does not play anything it should quit however.

To see if this functionality is also implemented in the Media Player Indicator, stop playback before you are able to terminate Rhythmbox.

share|improve this answer
    
The way it should operate by design is that whenever you close the window of a media player while it is playing it should minimize. The cross should always quit an application definitely and never daemonize it. a second button to daemonize application that can be should be created instead –  Kiwy Apr 15 at 10:48
    
@Kiwy: you may have entirely misunderstood my answer here. I am not talking about how I feel an application should behave, but I just said how it was implemented in the Media Player Indicator. I fully agree with you that this implementation is confusing ;) –  Takkat Apr 15 at 11:14
    
well sorry than, I would cancel my downvote if you edit your answer, just a space would be enough ;) –  Kiwy Apr 15 at 13:32

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.